NVIDIA Recalls Linux Drivers Over Fan Speed Bug

[md1032]

How come there isn't some built in protection in the hardware itself, when heat reaches hellish levels ?

They do, which is why almost all of the reports are, "My game is slow!" and not, "My GPU burned up!"

[oyvind]

Glad I'm not a gamer and my Nvidia card is passively cooled (I did install those drivers..). No jet engine noise, no problems with ball bearings going to hell in those utterly crappy GPU fans, and no problems with the fans not running at all because someone fscked up some driver code.

How come there isn't some built in protection in the hardware itself, when heat reaches hellish levels ?

[energyman]

Sure, they dont give out specs and docs, but at least they have a working binary driver, does amd have one? and stop complaining about the evil driver killing GPU`s!!! does somebody`s GPU "Went to a better place" because of the driver??? Dont forget, it was Nvidia Binary driver that made posible compiz, wine..... and so.I have an nvidia and wait everyday for Nouveau, but, the truth is that nouveau is not coming with decent OGL for a long time. Til then, go "Nvidia Binary Blob" thingy)

yes, there are enough reports of dead cards because of this driver.

So.. what do you choose? A driver that works good enough or a driver that will destroy your hardware?

[energyman]

WHQL only means 'this driver will not kill windows or other drivers with WHQL certification'. There is no guarantee that it works.

oh and:
[nelson] HA HA [/nelson]

[DeepDayze]

I have an nVidia 7900GS in my custom desktop and using the 195.38.08 driver. Haven't seen the anomaly yet with my card, but there should be a killswitch within the card's BIOS or temp sensor that'll shutdown the card if it overheats.

[Xemanth]

no passiv is Danger (i do not make fun)! only passiv with an massiv 120X120mm or 140X140mm Fan give you a real chance to win against that kind of bug.

for exampel Furmark can burn a passiv VGA witout a real good case-fan construction.

on my system my powersuply do have a 140X140 and my CPUs do have 2KG weight heatpiped Scythe Mugen-Infinity with 2. 120X120 fan and a case fan 120x120

and my VGA is massiv heatpipep passiv cooled .

yes passive but 3 pieces of 120X120 and 1 140X140 save the system

if you build pure passiv furmark will burn your VGA! ..

What card do you have?

[not.sure]

I think some GPUs did actually die.

Wouldn't be surprised if the (defective) G84 and G86 are the first to burn.

[portets43]

i'm running 195.36.3 on my laptop. laptop graphics cards are cooled differently, right?

this driver is about the same for me as with other drivers. with any blob driver i've used i get around 50C to 60C at idle and 60C to 75C under load. also, my laptop fan has only sped to full speed once in the past year that i've owned it.

any of that bad?^

[lem79]

I saw a high core temperature on my GTX260 last night (running 195.36.08, Ubuntu 9.10 AMD64) after suspend/resume. Core temp was 83C, compiz running, GPU/mem clocks @ 300/100MHz (idle).

I downgraded to 195.30 (without reboot), and the GPU temp dropped 30C to 53C. The air coming out of the back of the GPU was the same speed and temperature (measured by feeling the air).

I didn't try running Unigine Tropics or anything with 195.36.08 while the high temperature was being reported, just in case it was real. But, seeing as the air felt the same, I thought maybe it was just a driver bug reading the temperature incorrectly?

[Melcar]

I think some GPUs did actually die.