Apple Not Yet Committing LLVM/Clang A7 Support
Apple released the iPhone 5S today and it's powered by their own A7 chip, which is a 64-bit ARM SoC and claims to be up to twice the CPU and graphics performance of its predecessor. The Apple A7 SoC has over one billion transistors and its interesting to see it being a 64-bit processor while ARM doesn't yet have out its own 64-bit chips in the wild yet. While the A7 is interesting, Apple isn't yet ready to comment on the compiler support.
After today's iPhone 5S unveiling, the matter of A7 support for LLVM/Clang was brought up on the mailing list. Apple is a key backer to LLVM/Clang and employ many of its key contributors. LLVM/Clang is used now at the heart of both OS X and iOS and has superseded GCC in Apple's development stack. While Apple is surely using LLVM/Clang on the A7 SoC, they aren't yet ready to talk about it or commit open-source support.
In response to the mailing list thread, Eli Friedman a key Clang contributor and Apple employee, simply wrote, "We can't say anything at the moment."
The A7-based iPhone 5S will be released before month's end so hopefully at that time we'll have a better idea how it compares to ARM's AArch64 and in due time see open-source support in upstream LLVM/Clang -- hopefully before the 3.4 release before year's end.
Update: LLVM project leader Chris Lattner has now responded with, "A number of you have asked about the 64-bit CPU in the iPhone 5s, and what that means for LLVM. The iPhone 5s is based on the ARMv8 / Aarch64 instruction set, but the clang compiler in Xcode 5 is based on a custom LLVM Aarch64 backend, not the one currently on llvm.org. Apple is committed to contributing its Aarch64 backend to the community (merging it "the right way" with the existing backend), but it was a significant amount of work, and will take at least several months to work out all the details. I'll keep you posted."
After today's iPhone 5S unveiling, the matter of A7 support for LLVM/Clang was brought up on the mailing list. Apple is a key backer to LLVM/Clang and employ many of its key contributors. LLVM/Clang is used now at the heart of both OS X and iOS and has superseded GCC in Apple's development stack. While Apple is surely using LLVM/Clang on the A7 SoC, they aren't yet ready to talk about it or commit open-source support.
In response to the mailing list thread, Eli Friedman a key Clang contributor and Apple employee, simply wrote, "We can't say anything at the moment."
The A7-based iPhone 5S will be released before month's end so hopefully at that time we'll have a better idea how it compares to ARM's AArch64 and in due time see open-source support in upstream LLVM/Clang -- hopefully before the 3.4 release before year's end.
Update: LLVM project leader Chris Lattner has now responded with, "A number of you have asked about the 64-bit CPU in the iPhone 5s, and what that means for LLVM. The iPhone 5s is based on the ARMv8 / Aarch64 instruction set, but the clang compiler in Xcode 5 is based on a custom LLVM Aarch64 backend, not the one currently on llvm.org. Apple is committed to contributing its Aarch64 backend to the community (merging it "the right way" with the existing backend), but it was a significant amount of work, and will take at least several months to work out all the details. I'll keep you posted."
21 Comments