Originally posted by arQon
View Post
From where i sit, Wayland is one of those typical reinvention cases, promising that everything will be golden in 6 months, fixing what was broken on the previous implementation, but throwing everything good away as well. That never works out, as _everything_ gets reinvented, and several features get dropped (remote X anyone?). Aaron Plattners presentation X extension from 2007 was totally ignored for instance, and that should have gotten us some quite steps towards a 3d engine based window rendering model for X.
The only reason that it actually succeeded, for a value thereof, is that Kristian was part of red hat, and then intel, and thus part of the only political class that is allowed to reinvent things. Which is the prime reason why Mir failed, only some people are allowed to do anything major in the world of X/fd.o, everything else will be trampled.
Here i am, 8 years ago (so mir is older than 8ys), explaining how i see the Mir vs Wayland thing, when intel driver developers were forced to remove a tiny bit of Mir driver side support, by intel management: https://libv.livejournal.com/25325.html Intel is a hw company btw, and should care about maximising its driver support across its userbase. They should not limit the applicability of their driver support because of some political games at a much higher software level.
There seems to be a temporal correlation between the above games and Kristian moving away from working on Wayland at Intel, and then later moving to google. I have not been out drinking with Kristian since, so i have had no chance to ask him what happened.
Comment