Bcachefs Changes Rejected Reportedly Due To CoC, Kernel Future "Uncertain"

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Errinwright
    Senior Member
    • Aug 2023
    • 189

    The Linux foundation isn't upholding their CoC in virtually every other case, including when transgressions are by Linus himself. This CoC violation complaint is absurd to say the least, based on the quotes.

    Comment

    • TheMightyBuzzard
      Senior Member
      • Sep 2021
      • 416

      Originally posted by Daktyl198 View Post

      Your first example is an example of voting by committee, just with extra steps. Your next two examples are censorship, not to mention pussyfooting around the problem. It's amazing that the "anti-woke" crowd has gone so far, they've wrapped right back around to censorship and not hurting people's feelings lmao.
      It's not even supposed to be about censorship. It's about whose house you're at. The minute Linus let someone else decide what's appropriate behavior in his house is when it went from making sense to being absurd.

      Comment

      • Errinwright
        Senior Member
        • Aug 2023
        • 189

        Originally posted by Quackdoc View Post
        I love this thread so much, basically kent disagreed, michal said it was discused in a previous thread, kent asked for thread, michal said to find it himself, kent accused him of being insane because he again, couldn't find the thread and people refused to provide it, michal said kent was incapable of not being insane, kent told michal to get his head examined, shuah said the behavior is inexcusable (but saying kent is incapable of not being insane isn't)
        This entirely ordeal is completely absurd, and the fact that people are jumping onto the witch hunt is genuinely going to hurt Linux moving forward. Setting this as a standard will be impossible to meet.

        Comment

        • nz_monkey
          Junior Member
          • Aug 2024
          • 1

          Originally posted by energyman View Post

          People like Kent destroy projects. Nothing they do has any worth in the long run. His fs might be exciting and shiny. So what? Linux has plenty of exciting and shiny fs to pick from. Without some wannabe dictator like Kent screwing around in the background.
          The problem is, it doesn't....

          bcachefs is by and far the biggest development in Linux filesystems since Linux has existed.

          It allows:
          - Copy On Write
          - Device Classes (Caching/Tiering)
          - Erasure Coding
          - Encryption
          - Compression

          Within a single filesystem. No need for MD or LVM underlays, no need for block layer caches. It does it all.



          Comment

          • guzz46
            Phoronix Member
            • Jan 2012
            • 100

            The Linux world is having serious issues lately with this code of conduct nonsense

            Comment

            • F.Ultra
              Senior Member
              • Feb 2010
              • 2052

              Originally posted by jonnyheggheim View Post

              It's Linus project and he is free to do whatever he wants, but according to the CoC he is not allowed to discriminate by nationality. It is double standards when the CoC is used against Kent, but not against Linus.
              Linus have not banned or kicked out any one by nationality. Zero Russians have been banned, yet this myth keeps on being posted over and over and over, almost like it is part of some propaganda machinery...

              Comment

              • rmfx
                Senior Member
                • Jan 2019
                • 763

                Between the Russian devs kicked out, now this, what's the next step? a DEI department for the Linux kernel ?

                Comment

                • arcivanov
                  Junior Member
                  • Feb 2020
                  • 32

                  Banning Russians and others working in sanctioned organizations. They are not banned for Russian nationality.

                  Comment

                  • lyamc
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2020
                    • 528




                    Originally posted by JPFSanders View Post

                    You poison and derail every single thread you post in consistently and without fault, you ask about contributions but all you do is spew bile and lies whatever the subject is
                    Based on your own standards, you should be banned first

                    Originally posted by skeevy420 View Post
                    QUIT ATTACKING ME.
                    You're a crybully.

                    Originally posted by Alexmitter View Post

                    Lets look at those "idiotic" and "arbitary" rules:

                    Don't insult someone
                    Is it not insulting to reject a PR and not explain why?

                    ---------

                    ---------

                    The ultimate irony is the CoC hall monitors are the ones who really stirred up drama that made Linux look bad by coming in after the adults had already sorted everything out.

                    This, and another interaction Kent had sounded like the Unhelpful Helper:

                    As we know maladaptive social signals are behaviors that can be witnessed by others in such a way that they keep us out of the tribe.   In RO DBT social signals are posited as a unique and powerful mechanism of …


                    Do people honestly think that you can't handle bad actors without a CoC?

                    A CoC is not helpful.

                    For example, Alexmitter somehow managed to summarize the entire CoC with 3 words. I haven't checked but that's probably a better compression than zstd could achieve.


                    Comment

                    • erniv2
                      Senior Member
                      • Apr 2022
                      • 284

                      Rofl is this CoC the manly thing you do to protect your territory.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X