Originally posted by microcode
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
AMD Radeon Pro WX 3200 Announced As A Small Form Factor $199 USD Workstation Card
Collapse
X
-
-
Originally posted by skeevy420 View Post
Yeah, but it kind of sucks in regards to value since it's only slightly better than a 560 in some regards and worse in others.
Might as well buy a $170 8GB RX 570 with some games bundle to get better performance, twice the memory, less money, and some games in the process.
It's all about using proper tool for a particular job. CAD/CAM requires precision from microns to kilometers, gaming cards generally fail at providing such (games never require anything like this) and if not (rare exceptions), lack of error correction means, errors creeping in won't be corrected.
In real world it might manifest in some bridge collapsing or building falling apart due to error in structural calculations.
Yeah, you may learn CAD/CAM using gaming card, just mess around and familiarize yourself with the programs. For serious work, forget it.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by skeevy420 View Postget the low slot profile stuff and extra display ports, but other than that it isn't a very worthwhile card. 4GB of ram for 8K...you know as well as I do that that's barely adequate; probably with gimmicky "look what we can do" level of performance like regular Nvidia cards running ray tracing stuff have when compared to actual RTX cards.
It's not like this GPU has ECC or lots of other "Pro" features. Going by the "features" tab at AMD.com, the only things it has that the RX 570 doesn't is OpenGL 4.6*, 8K, Radeon Pro Renderer support**, and some more ports. It's seems to me like AMD just tweaked the firmware on some overstock RX 550 and 560 chips and slapped them on older WX boards to get rid of excess inventories.
Basically, if form-factor, OpenGL 4.6*, 8K, or the extra ports aren't deciding factors then an RX 570 is the better choice, gaming GPU or not really isn't a factor since it's just a better all around GPU and costs less -- they have 8GB Asus 570s on sale for $150 right now over at Newegg...
Sort of related -- After looking at so many "feature" tabs today, AMD really needs to asterisk the stuff that Linux doesn't support or is Windows' Only, like Virtual Super Resolution. Outside of gaming I like to VSR Windows to 2K from 1080p and I kind of feel cheated when I see that listed as a supported feature when it's really just a Windows feature.Last edited by schmidtbag; 02 July 2019, 07:09 PM.
- Likes 1
Leave a comment:
-
Cool, I was looking for basically exactly this card. Needed four DisplayPorts and a bit of GPU juice; and 200USD is a reasonable price for that.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by schmidtbag View PostWell, nobody buys a workstation GPU like this for the sake of gaming. What you're paying for is better reliability, better customer support, and in this case, 4x display connectors in pretty much the smallest form factor a GPU can get. It's meant for a multi-monitor office PC. I'm not sure you can get a single-slot low-profile RX 570, regardless of the amount of display outputs it supports.
It's not like this GPU has ECC or lots of other "Pro" features. Going by the "features" tab at AMD.com, the only things it has that the RX 570 doesn't is OpenGL 4.6*, 8K, Radeon Pro Renderer support**, and some more ports. It's seems to me like AMD just tweaked the firmware on some overstock RX 550 and 560 chips and slapped them on older WX boards to get rid of excess inventories.
Basically, if form-factor, OpenGL 4.6*, 8K, or the extra ports aren't deciding factors then an RX 570 is the better choice, gaming GPU or not really isn't a factor since it's just a better all around GPU and costs less -- they have 8GB Asus 570s on sale for $150 right now over at Newegg...
Realistically, only the ports and form factor are deciding factors here. 4GB is rather lame for 8K and there isn't enough OGL 4.6 content for that to even matter.
*Depending on what RX 570 you pick, it might support OpenGL 4.6. OEM ones do and regular ones don't...go figure...
**RX 580s beat WX 7200s, their workstation counterpart, in benchmarks and they don't technically support Radeon Pro Renderer either. Nvidia desktop GPUs kick ass as well. Just to show that "professional workstation cards" aren't necessarily needed for "professional workstation tasks" with modern GPUs...especially this GPU since it's really only Pro in name and could have just as easily been called RX 565 Low Profile because that is what it is...I guess 8K text editing is supposed to make it a Pro card...
Sort of related -- After looking at so many "feature" tabs today, AMD really needs to asterisk the stuff that Linux doesn't support or is Windows' Only, like Virtual Super Resolution. Outside of gaming I like to VSR Windows to 2K from 1080p and I kind of feel cheated when I see that listed as a supported feature when it's really just a Windows feature.
- Likes 2
Leave a comment:
-
Interesting board but I’m still surprised it is Polaris based. Given that I’m looking at a CAD engineering workstation build in the fall. I will have to keep this card in mind even if it might be a bit underpowered for a long term build.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by skeevy420 View PostYeah, but it kind of sucks in regards to value since it's only slightly better than a 560 in some regards and worse in others.
Might as well buy a $170 8GB RX 570 with some games bundle to get better performance, twice the memory, less money, and some games in the process.
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by bridgman View Post560 (Baffin) die has 16 CU's, 550 (Lexa) die has 10 IIRC. The board you linked appears to have 8 CU's enabled.
Still, good to know there is a single-slot consumer Polaris out there... hadn't realized that, thanks !
Leave a comment:
-
I have a couple big boxes sitting around, with expensive high-end toys inside. My interest in games has withered away and I'm not a "creator" so it's all overkill. Next machine I build will be small and quiet. A 6.6-inch $199 card would interest me.
Leave a comment:
-
560 (Baffin) die has 16 CU's, 550 (Lexa) die has 10 IIRC. The board you linked appears to have 8 CU's enabled.
Still, good to know there is a single-slot consumer Polaris out there... hadn't realized that, thanks !
- Likes 3
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: