Linus Wants Nouveau Merged Into Kernel

Posted by Michael Larabel on December 10, 2009

This morning the first DRM pull request went in for the Linux 2.6.33 kernel that brings many nice graphics changes for Intel, ATI/AMD, and VMware users. Anything for NVIDIA hardware through Novueau was not mentioned as there is no readied support, but as we stated in our article this morning, its unlikely to see Nouveau's DRM in the mainline kernel before the Linux 2.6.34 kernel. This is even though Fedora has been shipping Nouveau support for a few releases now and even Canonical is pulling in Nouveau KMS support for Ubuntu 10.04.

In response to David's DRM pull request, Linus Torvalds had the following to say (and no, this time he is not calling the code untested crap) on the mailing list:

No, the biggest missing feature is that Fedora is _still_ shipping Nouveau, and I'm _still_ not seeing Red Hat people actively trying to get it merged into mainline.

What the _hell_ is going on?

Linus

In response, Xavier Bestel was quick to reiterate that at last check the Nouveau developers still want the option of changing their kernel/user-space interface. Per standard Linux practice, once the code has been upstreamed in the mainline Linux kernel, the kernel/user API needs to be maintained to avoid causing any breaks for the user.

The Nouveau project has been around for a few years now and they have kernel mode-setting working on nearly all NVIDIA hardware along with many features like RandR 1.2, NouveauFB, suspend/resume, and there is support emerging for its Gallium3D driver (Nouveau status update), but the developers are still not confident in their API.

Linus has responded to Xavier with:

I've heard all the excuses. If it isn't ready, they shouldn't ship it to millions of people. And if it's ready, they should work on merging it.

No excuses.

Linus

By shipping it to millions of people he is referring to Red Hat shipping Nouveau with Fedora, which has been their default NVIDIA driver for two releases. David Airlie nor any of the Nouveau developers have yet to comment on this thread, but we are awaiting their response(s).

If we can see Nouveau's DRM get into the kernel soon (Linux 2.6.34 or 2.6.35?) and then a release of their xf86-video-nouveau X.Org driver, we have hopes of seeing the death of the obfuscated, trouble-ridden, feature-limited xf86-video-nv driver in 2010 by the time that X.Org 7.6 rolls around in October of 2010.

Discuss this article in our forums, IRC channel, or email the author. You can also follow our content via RSS and on social networks like Facebook, Identi.ca, and Twitter (@Phoronix and @MichaelLarabel). Subscribe to Phoronix Premium to view our content without advertisements, view entire articles on a single page, and experience other benefits.
Latest Hardware Reviews
  1. Gallium3D Continues Improving OpenGL For Older Radeon GPUs
  2. 15-Way Open vs. Closed Source NVIDIA/AMD Linux GPU Comparison
  3. Nouveau vs. NVIDIA Linux Comparison Shows Shortcomings
  4. AMD Radeon Gallium3D More Competitive With Catalyst On Linux
Latest Software Articles
  1. Btrfs vs. EXT4 vs. XFS vs. F2FS On Linux 3.10
  2. AMD Radeon R600 GPU LLVM 3.3 Back-End Testing
  3. F2FS File-System Shows Regressions On Linux 3.10
  4. Previewing The Radeon Gallium3D Shader Optimizations
Latest Linux News
  1. Modern Intel Gallium3D Driver Still Being Toyed With
  2. Linux 3.10 Kernel Benchmarks On A Core i7 Laptop
  3. GCC 4.8.1 Compiler Due To Be Out Next Week
  4. Linux 3.10 Kernel Benchmarks For Intel Ivy Bridge
  5. Linux's "Ondemand" Governor Is No Longer Fit
  6. Firefox 22 Beta Enables WebRTC Support
  7. OpenSUSE 13.1 Milestone 1 Released
  8. DRM Graphics Driver Comes For Dove/Cubox
  9. JADE: An LLVM-Based Video Decoder For MPEG RVC
  10. Ubuntu 13.10 Likely Switching To Chromium Browser
  11. Unity 7, Compiz To Be Polished For Ubuntu 13.10
Latest Forum Talk
  1. Btrfs vs. EXT4 vs. XFS vs. F2FS On Linux 3.10
  2. Radeon Gallium3D Gets Important Cayman Fixes
  3. Linux's "Ondemand" Governor Is No...
  4. Modern Intel Gallium3D Driver Still Being Toyed...
  5. Ubuntu 13.10 Likely Switching To Chromium Browser
  6. KDE's Krita Ported To OpenGL 3.1, OpenGL ES 2.0
  1. Computers
  2. Display Drivers
  3. Graphics Cards
  4. Motherboards
  5. Peripherals
  6. Processors
  7. Software
  8. Operating Systems
  9. All Articles
  1. Linux Benchmarking
  2. OpenBenchmarking.org
  3. Phoronix Test Suite