Intel's Poulsbo Driver A Bloody Mess?
Posted by Michael Larabel on January 31, 2009
Most of the Intel Atom netbooks currently on the market (like the Lenovo IdeaPad S10, Samsung NC10, and ASUS Eee PC) use the GMA 950 Chipset for their integrated graphics, but some of the newer models are using the Intel GMA 500. The GMA 500 doesn't share many traits with other mobile Intel IGPs since much of the technology was licensed from PowerVR, which means a different X.Org display driver is required.
Rather than using the xf86-video-intel driver that receives active development from Intel and is often leading the other open-source X.Org drivers when it comes to features like the Graphics Execution Manager, kernel mode-setting, and DRI2, a new driver had to be created for the GMA 500. The driver for the Intel GMA 500 "Poulsbo" Chipset was created by Intel and Tungsten Graphics. Unfortunately, this driver is very ill maintained.
The xf86-video-psb driver was the one written for the Poulsbo chipset and it hasn't seen any new development activity since last March. This driver isn't even hosted at FreeDesktop.org with the rest of the X.Org packages but instead is over at Moblin.org. The kernel module for this driver also hasn't been worked on since last March (Git viewer) and isn't upstream.
With the X.Org Poulsbo driver not being actively maintained, it doesn't even build with the latest Linux packages. If things couldn't get worse, the Intel Poulsbo driver depends upon a binary blob. The blob found in this file is called msvdx_fw.bin and if not installed will prevent you from utilizing 3D or video acceleration. Not only is there that headache, but there is also another dependent blob called Xpsb that is required.
The X.Org driver situation for the Intel Poulsbo (GMA 500) certainly seems like a bloody mess. Adam Williamson of Red Hat (previously known for his Mandriva work) has shared some of his Poulsbo experiences. We will only be seeing more Intel Poulsbo devices enter the marketplace, so hopefully Tungsten or Intel will be able to correct this situation. Right now, one of the only good things about this driver is that it supports VA-API for video acceleration.
Share your thoughts on this situation in the Phoronix Forums.
Rather than using the xf86-video-intel driver that receives active development from Intel and is often leading the other open-source X.Org drivers when it comes to features like the Graphics Execution Manager, kernel mode-setting, and DRI2, a new driver had to be created for the GMA 500. The driver for the Intel GMA 500 "Poulsbo" Chipset was created by Intel and Tungsten Graphics. Unfortunately, this driver is very ill maintained.
The xf86-video-psb driver was the one written for the Poulsbo chipset and it hasn't seen any new development activity since last March. This driver isn't even hosted at FreeDesktop.org with the rest of the X.Org packages but instead is over at Moblin.org. The kernel module for this driver also hasn't been worked on since last March (Git viewer) and isn't upstream.
With the X.Org Poulsbo driver not being actively maintained, it doesn't even build with the latest Linux packages. If things couldn't get worse, the Intel Poulsbo driver depends upon a binary blob. The blob found in this file is called msvdx_fw.bin and if not installed will prevent you from utilizing 3D or video acceleration. Not only is there that headache, but there is also another dependent blob called Xpsb that is required.
The X.Org driver situation for the Intel Poulsbo (GMA 500) certainly seems like a bloody mess. Adam Williamson of Red Hat (previously known for his Mandriva work) has shared some of his Poulsbo experiences. We will only be seeing more Intel Poulsbo devices enter the marketplace, so hopefully Tungsten or Intel will be able to correct this situation. Right now, one of the only good things about this driver is that it supports VA-API for video acceleration.
Share your thoughts on this situation in the Phoronix Forums.
Discuss this article in our forums, IRC channel, or email the author. You can also follow our content via RSS and on social networks like Facebook, Identi.ca, and Twitter (@Phoronix and @MichaelLarabel). Subscribe to Phoronix Premium to view our content without advertisements, view entire articles on a single page, and experience other benefits.
Copyright © 2004 - 2013 by Phoronix Media.
All trademarks used are properties of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Legal Disclaimer & Disclosure.
Powered by the Phoronix Content Management System (PHXCMS-7.4).
All trademarks used are properties of their respective owners. All rights reserved. Legal Disclaimer & Disclosure.
Powered by the Phoronix Content Management System (PHXCMS-7.4).