1. Computers
  2. Display Drivers
  3. Graphics Cards
  4. Memory
  5. Motherboards
  6. Processors
  7. Software
  8. Storage
  9. Operating Systems


Facebook RSS Twitter Twitter Google Plus


Phoronix Test Suite

OpenBenchmarking.org

NIR Still Being Discussed For Mesa, LLVM Gets Brought Up Again

Mesa

Published on 27 August 2014 01:37 PM EDT
Written by Michael Larabel in Mesa
44 Comments

Last week NIR was announced as a new intermediate representation for Mesa. Discussion around this new but experimental IR continues to happen among upstream developers while Mesa developers are back to discussing LLVM too.

Mesa developers appear interested in NIR but it's not clear yet that anyone is committed to finishing up and hooking up to the drivers this new intermediate representation that's lower-level than GLSL IR that supports SSA and is typeless. Those wishing to learn more of the gritty details being discussed can browse through the lengthy mailing list thread.

Along with NIR, Mesa developers are back to discussing LLVM and its IR possibilities for Mesa. While LLVM is used extensively by Radeon (R600g/RadeonSI) and LLVMpipe drivers most notably, Intel has been the main Mesa contributor against LLVM. At multiple stages of Intel's Linux graphics driver history with Mesa had been plans to develop an Intel LLVM back-end and other LLVM investigations for Intel's GPU driver, but in the end they've become opposed to LLVM.

Their opposition to using LLVM in their graphics driver comes down to the significant work in rewriting their compiler back-end and the significant amount of upfront work they must invest in this back-end before seeing any return on investment with LLVM's optimization potential, etc. The Intel driver has also seen a bumpy road in the past when reworking large parts of their Linux graphics driver stack and are looking to avoid such fallout going forward.

Besides Intel not being interested in the upfront challenge and the headaches involved in learning the ins and outs of LLVM, other common issues with LLVM Mesa usage come down to LLVM's lack of a stable API (it generally breaks release-to-release), the different LLVM release schedule, and packaging challenges for distribution vendors, among other potential issues. It's been brought up again in this NIR mailing list thread about potentially bundling the LLVM source tree within Mesa, but that too entails a different set of headaches.

The latest in the NIR thread proposes using LLVM's C API to write a translator from Mesa's GLSL IR into LLVM IR, utilize LLVM's optimization abilities, and then give the driver back-ends the option of using the LLVM IR. This approach would at least allow once and for all the Mesa developers to see in close detail how useful LLVM's optimizers are in practice for Mesa. However, no developers have yet committed themselves to this work.

VMware isn't interested in contributing resources to this effort but Jose Fonseca of VMware noted in the NIR discussion, "even though it seems to me that Mesa will unavoidably eventually gravitate towards more wide-spread use of LLVM, I'm unable to help provide more critical mass myself. Which is why I don't oppose NIR. Even though it seems a less direct path than overcome the hurdles of using LLVM now, NIR's SSA-nature seems a step forward nevertheless. And of course, who does the job gets to decide how it's done."

NIR Still Being Discussed For Mesa, LLVM Gets Brought Up Again


Also worth bringing up again is the interesting work done by LunarG with LunarGLASS and the Valve-funded work on Glassy Mesa for incorporating LLVM into Mesa for offering increased driver performance.

In the end the usage of LLVM inside Mesa is most likely to grow and the existing challenges overcome, it's just a matter of time.

About The Author
Michael Larabel is the principal author of Phoronix.com and founded the web-site in 2004 with a focus on enriching the Linux hardware experience and being the largest web-site devoted to Linux hardware reviews, particularly for products relevant to Linux gamers and enthusiasts but also commonly reviewing servers/workstations and embedded Linux devices. Michael has written more than 10,000 articles covering the state of Linux hardware support, Linux performance, graphics hardware drivers, and other topics. Michael is also the lead developer of the Phoronix Test Suite, Phoromatic, and OpenBenchmarking.org automated testing software. He can be followed via and or contacted via .
Latest Linux Hardware Reviews
  1. Intel Xeon E5-1680 v3 & E5-2687W v3 Compared To The Core i7 5960X On Linux
  2. Intel 120GB 530 Series SSD Linux Performance
  3. Btrfs/EXT4/XFS/F2FS RAID 0/1/5/6/10 Linux Benchmarks On Four SSDs
  4. AMD's Windows Catalyst Driver Remains Largely Faster Than Linux Drivers
Latest Linux Articles
  1. NVIDIA vs. Nouveau Drivers With Linux 3.18 + Mesa 10.4-devel
  2. Is The Open-Source NVIDIA Driver Fast Enough For Steam On Linux Gaming?
  3. Linux 3.18 File-System Performance Minimally Changed But Possible Regressions
  4. AMD Radeon Gallium3D Is Catching Up & Sometimes Beating Catalyst On Linux
Latest Linux News
  1. Linux 3.18 Kernel: Not Much Change With Intel Haswell Performance
  2. More File-System Tests Of The Linux 3.18 Kernel
  3. Using NVIDIA's NVENC On Linux With FFmpeg
  4. There's Talk Again About An "Open To The Core" Ubuntu Laptop
  5. PowerVR SGX Driver Code Gets Leaked
  6. V2 Of KDBUS Published For Linux Kernel Review
  7. VirtualBox 4.3.20 Arrives, Still No Sign Of VirtualBox 4.4
  8. Scientific Linux 6.6 vs. Scientific Linux 7.0 Benchmarks
  9. Qualcomm Looks To Get Into The ARM Server Business
  10. HHVM 3.4 Adds New Features, Support
Latest Forum Discussions
  1. Roadmap to Catalyst 14.10 ?
  2. Updated and Optimized Ubuntu Free Graphics Drivers
  3. Cant get working Kaveri APU - A10-7850k
  4. Debian Developer Resigns From The Systemd Maintainership Team
  5. Script for Fan Speed Control
  6. Debian Init System Coupling Vote Results
  7. The Slides Announcing The New "AMDGPU" Kernel Driver
  8. Ubuntu Developers Still Thinking What To Do About Adobe Flash Support