Phoronix IRC Log: 2009-03-11

Kano: hi michaellarabel , did you install a usefull os on the x58 system?
Kano: also no changes to pts git, not even the hotfix i gave you...
ech0s7: hi
ech0s7: where can i find ati-catalyst 9.4 rc ?
superdump: i would have thought if it were available, either on ati.amd.com or there should be a link to sign up for the pre-release stuff in that article that was published a few days ago
tha: hi. im trying to get my x1400 running with radeonhd, X starts - but its not possible to run xvideo (no adaptors present)
orak3l: can somebody tell me where to get ati-driver-installer-8.60_RC1-x86.x86_64.run? ive searched the web already with no success. ive tried the torrents too, but there are no seeders
Kano: michaellarabel: you added the sg hotfix,but it still does not finish when i run the benchmark, how to debug that? it writes
Kano: Average: 127.53 Frames Per Second
Kano: and then it stops
michaellarabel: Yeah, I refreshed the Git server this morning.
michaellarabel: What do you mean by not finish?
Kano: it does not return to menu or when you start it from console it does not return to it. it just stays at that point
Kano: after the average value
Kano: when i check with htop, pts runs with 99% on one core at this time
Kano: i guess it is in same kind of endless loop
Kano: busy waiting for something
michaellarabel: I'll need to run it myself Kano to see if Ican reproduce it then
Kano: please do
Kano: sg usually runs only with 32 bit
michaellarabel: I will soon as I turn on a test system next
Kano: could you install linux on the x58 system?
michaellarabel: Not yet
Kano: send it to me, i am sure i could do ;)
Kano: maybe you have got a differnt sata controller
Kano: as when you have got a ide connector, then you have got a sata connector in most cases from that controller chip too
Kano: one ich10 or that connector should at least work
cxo: Any idea if we will see linux support for caustic graphics? http://vr-zone.com/forums/403168/new-graphics-player-onboard-to-fight-nvidia-and-amd.html
michaellarabel: cxo: I am contacting them...
cxo: good stuff
raevol: wow nice
raevol: wonder what the price will be
cxo: "Did you know that the average render time today for a single ray-traced image at film resolution is over three hours?"
cxo: they say their 2nd gen card coming out next year will be 200x faster
raevol: yea saw that
cxo: thats less than 1minute for a frame
raevol: "patent pending" on their algorithm
cxo: great, 20yrs before the rest of the world is allowed to use it
raevol: well, i guess if they don't patent it someone else will
raevol: *shrug*
cxo: i'm all for the underdog, Nvidia and ATi are just overweight and lazy these days
raevol: for sure
cxo: sadly, i've been using linux for so long, i've forgotten what playing games is like, i'm not even interested anymore
cxo: But if a new Hitman or Splinter Cell or Metal Gear Solid comes out, i'll have to try it out
raevol: yea i haven't had time for games, but i've definitely picked up an interest in them again
raevol: i can't be bothered to boot into windows though, that's why i'm keeping tabs on virtualbox
raevol: they have opengl working
cxo: basic dx8 and dx9 even
cxo: but basically if you could run it under wine, it would work in VBox, since its the same wine3d engine
cxo: so no point on a VBox installation just for games
raevol: well, i disagree
raevol: wine has to emulate the entire operating system, vbox just has to emulate the hardware (which works fantastic) and the directx->opengl conversion
raevol: much smaller room for error
cxo: ?
cxo: there is no directx->opengl done by VBox, its using wine3d dlls
raevol: yes
raevol: but that's the only part of wine it relies on
cxo: why emulate the entire OS if you dont need to?
raevol: if you run the game solely on wine, the game has to interact with the rest of wine
raevol: well wine is in a sense "emulating" the whole OS, it has to handle all calls made by the game, not just the rendering ones
cxo: of course, it does, whatever the game asks for
cxo: but Vbox has to run the entire OS, which means background MMU tasks, scheduling etc..
raevol: right, an if wine's implementation of those things is incomplete, it causes issues
cxo: yeah
raevol: right but at least VBox will just fundamentally work, since it doesn't run a reverse engineered implementation
cxo: except for 3d rendering
raevol: i see your point though
raevol: yea
cxo: have you tried GTA4 on Vbox? it doesnt work on wine because of some funky .net stuff
raevol: i haven't, is it opengl?
cxo: no, its dx9/dx10
raevol: it probably won't work them
raevol: then*, especially the dx10
cxo: why not?
raevol: wined3d doesn't really work in Vbox yet
cxo: oh, i just tried out dxdiag, and that ran fine, so i just assumed...
raevol: it did? did all the tests show the spinning box?
cxo: yeah
cxo: all passed
raevol: :o
raevol: wat!
cxo: dx9c
raevol: what wined3d did you use?
cxo: the patches from the vbox tracker
raevol: gah i must have used the wrong ones
cxo: http://www.virtualbox.org/ticket/2940
raevol: there's several linked on that ticket
cxo: well your supposed to build the dlls yourself
cxo: i think some guy posted links to his homepage with built dlls
raevol: yea i think i used those
raevol: crap i'll have to try this when i get home
raevol: did you build them yourself?
cxo: i did both, i tried the ones on the website first, dx7 failed, dx8, dx9 passed, then i built my own and dx7 passed too
raevol: hMmMmMm
raevol: man, i really want to try that now
raevol: later cxo
redeeman: udhcpd
redeeman: whoops
cxo: We need to start a charity, OLPH, One LinuxBox Per Hacker
cxo: needs a new box
cxo: preferable 1u please
bkero: Heh, tiny rackables
cxo: dual slot pci-e expansion, 1x PCI-E 2.0 16x
bkero: has some old 2u crap that work is throwing out
cxo: 2U = 2 Ugly
bkero: 1U = YOU're ugly
cxo: just installed C&C-RA3
cxo: seems to work
bkero: Fancy
cxo: the 7600gs, athlon 4200x2 is struggling though
cxo: sighs thinking about the perfectly fine hd4870 on the table
Kano: why dont you use it
cxo: Its not like ATi works under Linux
Kano: cxo: basically it works, just not with xserver 1.6
cxo: sure
cxo: The last ATi card i had that worked with wine was an Radeon 8500LE, some... 5years ago
michaellarabel: Kano: Do you recall where ALSA stores the name of the sound card(s) in use? I thought there was a place within /sys/ but I don't recall.
Kano: $ cat /proc/asound/cards
Kano: do you mean that?
michaellarabel: No. That just reports Intel HDA. I mean similar to where you run alsamixer -c 0 and see the chip. Like Analog Devices AD1984 for instance.
Kano: you want the codec?
michaellarabel: Ah. Did find it within /proc/asound/cardX/codec#0
Kano: head -1 /proc/asound/card0/codec*/*|head -2
Kano: it is not that easy,best look at the alsa script from #alsa
Kano: do you kwno that?
michaellarabel: Which alsa script?
Kano: the script they always ask to execute
Kano: http://www.alsa-project.org/alsa-info.sh
michaellarabel: cat /proc/asound/card*/codec\#* > $TEMPDIR/alsa-hda-intel.tmp 2> /dev/null they seem to have checks running off the same file
Kano: because it has some extra cases for hda, ac97
Kano: if you only check on new hardware you dont see the ac97 case
Kano: or old soundblaster
michaellarabel: On non-Intel systems is /proc/asound/cards more descriptive than just "HDA Intel"
Kano: yes it shows my sblive 5.1
michaellarabel: Okay
michaellarabel: Can you pastebin how it's outputted?
Kano: http://paste.debian.net/30394/
Kano: thats the older sb variante with hw mixing
michaellarabel: oooo got news on Caustic
Kano: maybe add a cron job to update the git repo
Kano: it always reports up-to-date
Kano: funny, you wrote about linpus *g*
Kano: i met em on cebit and they even wanted to see kanotix + splashtop running from usb drive *g*
cxo: wat tis this news
Kano: but the cd i got was not really good, it did not boot on my testsystem with g31
Kano: i guess it is only tested on those acer atom systems
cxo: hates atom
redeeman: lol
cxo: its slow, its power hungry, and its expensive
Kano: well i am no fan of it
redeeman: atom itself isn't really too power hungry
Kano: if you dont need to compile then it migh be ok however
cxo: thats like having an STD and saying sex itself isnt that dangerous
redeeman: no it's not
cxo: Atom sucks Nano balls
cxo: Nano FTW!
cxo: Even Toms did a review showing an underclocked athlon was faster, used less power and cheaper than an Atom setup
Kano: its all about marketing
cxo: considering you can get AM2, itx boards, why ever get an Atom
redeeman: cheaper to purchase maybe
redeeman: but far more costly to produce
redeeman: and with much less profit
cxo: oh yes, we must buy hardware that is cheapest to produce
cxo: who would ever buy anything that was cheapest to buy
redeeman: before the atom boards get more expensive they were SHIT cheap
redeeman: 44usd for the atom board
redeeman: you don't get no am2 cpu + board for that
redeeman: that's btw, bought in europe
Kano: well it is slow as hell..
redeeman: so 25% cheaper in usa
cxo: makes Atom suck his balls
Kano: ion plattform is dead before arrival because when it would be out then intel will combine gpu parts into the cpu
Kano: so all you get is mainly only intel gfx
cxo: 32nm i7 will have the gpu built in, will be definitely interesting to benchmark
cxo: has too much money in his restoration project for new computer toys this year
Kano: do you think the i7 will?
Kano: i dont
Kano: the consumer chip is most likely called i5
cxo: oh i dont know the name, but its on the same Nehalem arch
Kano: i5 is like i7 but only 2 ddr3 channels
Kano: and one will have got integrated gfx too
cxo: sounds enough for me
cxo: ddr3 needs 3 sticks for a full channel right?
redeeman: that question didn't make sense
Kano: yes, but most benchmarks are not much faster with 3 instead of 3
redeeman: i7 needs 3 sticks
Kano: err 2
Kano: it does not really _need_ 3
redeeman: no but for using all 3 channels :P
Kano: only for triple channel, it can use dual channel too
redeeman: 3 channels owns
redeeman: 6 sticks ;D
Kano: intel only adds 4 sockets
cxo: i dont get why things are all getting integrated again, really early boxes had everything, sound, video, cpu etc.. built into one card
Kano: must be tricky to use more than 4
cxo: then everything split up
cxo: now everything is being stuck together again?
cxo: i guess the manufacturing process has helped along the way
cxo: you can now have 2x 8 core i7 chips in the same space as my Athlon, so why not stick everything together
Kano: i am not fully sure, but the gfx part is somehow "added", it is not on the same dye
cxo: so i guess we're going to get a new graphics bus
Kano: just like the quad cores from intel
cxo: its not like they are going to try access pci-e straight from the CPU
Kano: i will not be faster that way
Kano: just cheaper
redeeman: it could be faster
Kano: currently you need a north+southbridge
redeeman: they can clock it higher that way
redeeman: easier
Kano: redeeman: intel onboard was never fast compared to other solutions
cxo: whatever happened to larranbee
cxo: its all quite now
cxo: ^quiet
Kano: i think they do not really want to sell it as gfx card only
cxo: Intel is Evil
Kano: more like application accellerators
redeeman: that was the plan yes
Kano: to compete against the cuda cards from nvidia
redeeman: they should come in quickpath versions too
cxo: Evilness scale, Microsft > Google > Intel > Apple
redeeman: LOL
redeeman: crapple is much worse than any of those others
Kano: i just think that that chip might now be fast enough for standard 3d accelleration. because "real" gfx cards use much more parallelism
Kano: as they are basically full pentium cores maybe intel wants to show some apps which user raytracing
cxo: Pentium rocked ass baby
Kano: do you think 16 or 32 pentiums will be faster with crysis or another next gen game?
cxo: i think it would be the same as a modern high end gfx card, or a little less
redeeman: kano it's not just standard pentiums
redeeman: it has more floating point power than any nvidia card
Kano: the highend gfx chips have a higher transistor count than i7
redeeman: it has 512bit vector instructions
Kano: redeeman: could change with dx11, not fully sure
redeeman: every core can do 16 single precision floating point operations each cycle
Kano: well no test systems out there yet, would be interesting...
cxo: i think 32 HD4870 cores at 32nm would be way faster
redeeman: i don't think you realize what kind of comparisin it is you are doing
cxo: yeah so along those lines, nvidia could just make a 32 core version of the geforce 256, that card really rocked
Kano: there are not only 32 shader cores, there are over 200...
redeeman: exactly
cxo: no not shaders, the entire chip
redeeman: but lol
cxo: fuk shaders, who uses that crap even
Kano: 240 shader, 32 render, 80 texture engine has a gtx 28x
redeeman: that's the most stupid thing you ever said
redeeman: because that would be like comparing 32 larrabee cards to a HD4870 card
cxo: No
redeeman: yes?
cxo: No
redeeman: and explain how it is different
Kano: those are special purpose cores, in 3 variants, intel uses always the same core, much more complex,but fewer
cxo: shader processors are just execution units just like how a regular has vector registers, alus etc... the P4 had 4 vector processors, the G4 had 12, etc.. so if the larrabee is a duplication of the entire Pentium core, it will have multiple of each execution unit
cxo: ^regular cpu
redeeman: larrabee is not a standard pentium core
Kano: yes, but can you say which variant is faster?
redeeman: it's merely based on it
Kano: yes it has some extra tricks in it
cxo: 32 core HD4870 FTW
redeeman: but the HD4870 is already comprised of many cores
michaellarabel: Caustic Graphics: http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=NzEzNg
cxo: what do you guys use for media player?
Deanjo: A Pioneer 8-track
Kano: 160 shaders for 4870
cxo: i'm getting tired of amarok
Kano: then use itunes with wine ;)
Deanjo: Ya saw that caustic graphics card michaellarabel, flashbacks of Physx's cards and Voodoo's
Kano: michaellarabel: please test sg, maybe you find the error.
Kano: bye for now
Deanjo: Can't see it being a competitor to nv or ati though, still required a videocard to function
cxo: i think my balls can be a competitor to ATi
cxo: Isnt Nvidia still crying about X58 even? Good time to start a graphics company it hink
Deanjo: Well that's true, they are just as rash red :P
cxo: inspects
cxo: hmm not at the moment!
Deanjo: Caustic reminds me too much of another start up company crying "Buy us out please!!!!"
cxo: it all depends on how money hungry the CEO is
Deanjo: Heh, they all are money hungry, did you take a look at where the head honcho's come from?
cxo: No, i heard it was an a mix up of a lot of X big name employees
michaellarabel: Apple
Deanjo: Ya they are former Autodesk, Apple, ATI, Intel and NVIDIA employees
Deanjo: Sort of sounds like the make up of the 3dlabs guys
cxo: SGI even once upon a time
Deanjo: Headlines today, 6 months down the line you will read "bought out by....."
cxo: So they're either going to get blown away by the money they make, not know how to manage it and go bankrupt or get fooled into a big project by the likes of Microsoft and become worthless and barely survive for decades to come
cxo: http://jalopnik.com/5168050/nebraska-car-dealers-disappear-take-dozens-of-cars-with-them
Deanjo: I remember the hype when these came out too http://www.mc.com/products/boards/accelerator_board2.aspx
cxo: tungston is doing a gallium drive for the Cell BE
cxo: i wonder if it works yet
Deanjo: Then there was other things like mpeg2/4 decoding cards which never really caught on, then there was the idea of popping out a cpu on a multiple cpu socketboard and popping in a cell or gpu or dedicated DSP into the same socket.....
Deanjo: It's pretty hard to get excited with products like this. They often promise big results only to fade away within a year
redeeman: pls2gief venture capital!!!!
Deanjo: lol, ya like that is easy to come by in todays economy for a tech firm
cxo: the mpeg decoding cards did get popular, but CPUs got faster
cxo: so what plans for the summer Deanjo
Deanjo: They never really caught on. Mpeg 2 cards basically there was the Creative labs card which was a knock off of the Hollywood + card from sigma designs.
Deanjo: The only mpeg 4 card was a sigma design card as well and died pretty quickly
Deanjo: Plans for the summer? Lots of beer
cxo: why does that require summer
Deanjo: Pretty hard to think about summer when today it hit -58 C with windchill
cxo: jeez, its only some -15degC here
cxo: wind is moving fast, 15m/s
cxo: I'm gearing up to rebuild the front end of the Jag
Deanjo: Ya we are supposed to get into the +4 range in a couple of days for the rest of next week
cxo: planning a mad road trip in V12, maybe to BC even
evocallaghan: Hi
evocallaghan: michaellarabel:Ping
michaellarabel: Hi evocallaghan
evocallaghan: Hey
evocallaghan: Looks like the cats out the bag and is going around like whild fire now
evocallaghan: http://osnews.com/comments/21123
evocallaghan: Thus I though I would keep you informed
evocallaghan: Maybe something a bit higher quality info from us for your readers ;)
evocallaghan: Got a min ?
michaellarabel: Actually was getting ready to call it a night.
evocallaghan: Oh, no worries
evocallaghan: up to you when to you really
evocallaghan: You know where we are to get something properly written up

< Phoronix IRC Home

Latest Hardware Reviews
  1. Sumo Lounge Emperor
  2. Gallium3D Continues Improving OpenGL For Older Radeon GPUs
  3. 15-Way Open vs. Closed Source NVIDIA/AMD Linux GPU Comparison
  4. Nouveau vs. NVIDIA Linux Comparison Shows Shortcomings
Latest Software Articles
  1. GCC 4.8.0 vs. LLVM Clang 3.3 Compiler Performance
  2. Intel Linux OpenGL Driver Leading Over Apple OS X
  3. The Cost Of Ubuntu Disk Encryption
  4. Btrfs vs. EXT4 vs. XFS vs. F2FS On Linux 3.10
Latest Linux News
  1. A New X.Org-Free Wayland LiveCD Released
  2. Unity 8, Mir Made Progress This Week On Features
  3. LLVM Clang 3.3 RC2 Is Ready For Testing
  4. AMD RadeonSI Gallium3D Begins Simple CL Demos
  5. Intel Shows Off GNOME3-Based Tizen Shell
  6. Linux Desktop Security Could Be A Whole Lot Better
  7. KDE 4.11 Will Be The Last Major KDE4 Workspaces Feature Release
  8. New NVIDIA Linux Driver Supports The GeForce GTX 780
  9. Chrome 28 To Offer More Speed Improvements
  10. Digia Announces "Boot To Qt" Project
  11. X.Org Libraries Hit By Round Of Security Issues
Latest Forum Talk
  1. A New X.Org-Free Wayland LiveCD Released
  2. Jolla Announces Their First Phone
  3. Steam: No used games...
  4. AMD RadeonSI Gallium3D Begins Simple CL Demos
  5. KDE 4.11 Will Be The Last Major KDE4 Workspaces...
  6. Intel Shows Off GNOME3-Based Tizen Shell
  1. Computers
  2. Display Drivers
  3. Graphics Cards
  4. Motherboards
  5. Peripherals
  6. Processors
  7. Software
  8. Operating Systems
  9. All Articles
  1. Linux Benchmarking
  2. OpenBenchmarking.org
  3. Phoronix Test Suite