Phoronix IRC Log: 2009-02-15

SlickMcRunfast: Requesting World of Goo Review
veckt_: hello. i'm using fedora and i have the "AMD unsupported hardware" logo problem: http://www.phoronix.com/forums/showthread.php?t=15192
veckt_: the problem can be solved by extracting some files from old catalyst packages... how do i get old packages? sorry, i'm kinda new to linux
rski: want to help an old fart out with getting starcraft to run
rski: i need to force X into 8bit.
rski: but even if i try 16 it just goes bonkers and won't start
Kano: michaellarabel: http://debian.org/News/2009/20090214
Ivanovic: michaellarabel: http://www.phoronix.com/forums/showthread.php?p=62944#post62944
bartmon: Hi!
bartmon: I'm just installing the universe test-suite, which is i guess every test. How much spae does it all take up?
bartmon: space even
Ivanovic: *much*
Ivanovic: many gigabyte, >10 that is
bartmon: Yeah, i looked at a couple of universe benches on global and saw many games on the list so i just cancelled the download
bartmon: i have an issue with test sunflow. It never completes and i think that happens because during installation there was a complaint "No installation script found for java-environment"
bartmon: and since sunflow is written in java i guess it'srequired
bartmon: does PTS use the system JRE?
Ivanovic: michaellarabel: you should know the answer for bartmon
michaellarabel: bartmon: System JRE it should install, yes. Try: phoronix-test-suite force-install sunflow
bartmon: Now it complains about "No installation script found for java-environment". BTW, I have both sun-java5-jre and sun-java6-jre installed.
bartmon: Well it's the same error as before. Let me add tgat I've installed PTS from the .deb file posted on the site.
michaellarabel: There should be no installation script for java-environment
pan_: can Phoronix Test Suite be ported to windows?
Azerthoth: in theory
Kano: cygwin maybe
pan_: but i see there is php cli for windows
Kano: well it uses also shell scripting
Kano: so you could try cgywin environment
pan_: oh yeah......
Kano: maybe it works for some compile benchmarks
pan_: yeah but performance testing and cygwin....i don't know.....
Kano: you want it, not me ;)
mo0n_sniper: :)
Kano: more interesting would be 3d tests
cxo: just died in LVMs arms
Kano: but then you would have to detect windows a bit better
michaellarabel: pan_: If you felt like submitting patches that abstracted all of the shell-scripting into a new PTS script :)
cxo: i was so close to totally fuking up my entire system
Kano: and change scripts to use the win executeable. should work for some games which provide both
Kano: old lvm + kernel 2.6.27+ was no joy ;)
mo0n_sniper: michaellarabel, well windows scripting it's not as good as linux scripting ;)
Kano: you basically have to update the complete os in order to use a newer lvm as you have build-deps down to libc6 2.4+
Kano: no joy..
michaellarabel: mo0n_sniper: Though a majority of the PTS scripting is all very basic
mo0n_sniper: Kano, also the 3d performance difference would make the users cry
mo0n_sniper: michaellarabel, if pts would run on windows then it would be the best benchmarking software around
Kano: mo0n_sniper: depends, on my own benchmarks some years ago games like doom3 did not force AF or AA correctly when specified in the game
maligor: maybe it'd work with Windows Services for Unix :P
Kano: mo0n_sniper: but that fault was only in the linux binary. so when you dont force it via driver overrides then Linux was definitely faster
michaellarabel: mo0n_sniper: I have no objections to accepting patches that would add clean Windows support, though I probably wouldn't write the support myself unless there was corporate interest.
Kano: so when you want to compare both, then you need to look into those issues as well
Kano: after forceing linux was 5% slower with nvidia, forgetable
mo0n_sniper: michaellarabel, it was only a indea ,I don't think i'm up for the task
Kano: but i guess fglrx would really drop more *g*
mo0n_sniper: :) yeah
mo0n_sniper: hope the new linux graphics overhaul will bring something......
maligor: what new linux graphics overhaul?
mo0n_sniper: dri2,gallium,kms
Kano: mo0n_sniper: when you use nvidia this does not matter at all
mo0n_sniper: you know like always the next big thing it's just around the corner
maligor: none of them will mean much to binary drivers
michaellarabel: Though maybe after PTS 2.0 when I start running out of ideas for new major features, I'll consider Windows support for the heck of it.
Kano: maligor: partly correct. fglrx does not replace that much as nvidia does
Kano: nvidia is really more radical ;)
mo0n_sniper: :) then i'll hope you run out of ideas :)
Kano: maligor: only the mesa opengl lib is replaced, rest are addon files for fglrx
Kano: compare that to nvidia ;)
maligor: actually ati ships a modified MESA libGL
mo0n_sniper: i remember installind linux to a friend with nvidia a year ago
maligor: or it's suspiciously close to mesa if it isn't :P
mo0n_sniper: everything worked compiz , wine, video ,native games....
mo0n_sniper: good for them because they got the job done
Kano: maligor: nvidia replace libglx.so + libGLcore.so too. i guess that prevents lots of abi breakages
maligor: Kano, you mean add
Kano: i mean replace
maligor: libGLcore doesn't exist
Kano: 102: /usr/lib/xorg/modules/extensions/libGLcore.so
maligor: true for libglx.so tho
Kano: thats in the log
maligor: I don't have that
Kano: -> /var/lib/nvidia/log
maligor: yes, I realize
maligor: but it's a new nvidia file, not a replacement
maligor: ati has similiar stuff also
maligor: libfglrxdrm.so
Kano: nope, the backup files are stored in /var/lib/nvidia
Kano: maligor: that not replaced, thats added
maligor: You have searched for paths that end with libGLcore in suite sid, all sections, and all architectures. Sorry, your search gave no results
Kano: /usr/lib/xorg/modules/extensions/libGLcore.so is in xserver-xorg-core
redeeman: nvidia does not provide libglcore here
redeeman: or well
maligor: maligor@purplemist:~$ dpkg -L xserver-xorg-core | grep libGLcore
maligor: maligor@purplemist:~$
redeeman: not in extensions
Kano: dpkg -L xserver-xorg-core | grep libGLcore
Kano: /usr/lib/xorg/modules/extensions/libGLcore.so
maligor: well, I'm running 1.5 tho
Kano: http://packages.debian.org/lenny/i386/xserver-xorg-core/filelist
redeeman: http://pastebin.com/mea678be
Kano: maligor: sid has no 1.5
maligor: Kano, you are correct
maligor: I wonder why it's vanished from experimental
redeeman: i just hope nvidia will fix their instabilities soon
redeeman: http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=123912
Kano: maligor: but experimental has 1.6
Kano: rc
Kano: 1.5.99
maligor: yeah, I'm stuck between
maligor: experimental had 1.5
Kano: well xserver 1.6 does not have got that file
Kano: but what i want to say is that nvidia replaces 3 not only 1 file
maligor: neither did 1.5
Kano: and does not have got so many abi issues
maligor: huh?
maligor: they have the same abi issues as fglrx
Kano: for fglrx you get new precompiled binarys for every abi step and older "half compatible" abi changes are not supported at all
Kano: the nvidia installer is small, every extra abi for fglrx makes the installer about 20 mb bigger
Kano: in 5 years it will be 200 mb then ;)
Kano: or 300
redeeman: lol
maligor: they could make a reconstructor
maligor: or binary diffs
redeeman: i remember years ago, i downloaded fglrx, it was 120mb
redeeman: then they cleaned up, and it became ~30mb
redeeman: but it's still ridicoules
Kano: even lzma compression would save about 49 %
maligor: what about adobe reader for linux?
redeeman: i fortunately never downloaded that garbage
cxo: i remember that
Kano: redeeman: it was never 120 mb
redeeman: Kano: i believe it was
cxo: i remember it being 94mb
Kano: redeeman: nope
redeeman: Kano: it was certainly 100mb+
redeeman: and i remember making a big fuss about it on irc, laughing my ass off
cxo: i even email ati about that
cxo: asking them why it was twice the size of the nvidia drivers
redeeman: it's obscene
Kano: use --extract then you know it ;)
redeeman: you can run fucking entire linux systems taking up less space
Kano: you can expect it growing in april or may by 20 mb again ;)
redeeman: i just made an embedded dist ~8mb
Kano: i have a script that can change the ati intaller, remove all unneeded archs, compress with lzma with lzmadec static embeeded
redeeman: that reminds me, anyone that has a good C benchmark? preferrably testing both cpu and linux performance
Kano: ati 8-7 32 bit only stripped down to 14 mb
Kano: redeeman: time on linux compile ;)
redeeman: im afraid i didn't bother giving the box it's own toolchain
Kano: nvidia drivers are 13-14 mb for 32 bit too. so basically they are same size when you compress em correctly ;)
Kano: nvidia with lzma is no big gain btw. maybe 1-2 mb
redeeman: http://pastebin.ca/1338487
redeeman: they probably encrypt their driver
redeeman: Kano: i wrote a small hanoi solver, and that box, at 130mhz, is 32 times slower than amd64 2ghz
Kano: well when you do objdump on nvidia you will not get anything readable, fglrx can be read like a book ;)
Kano: what i dont get is that there are libs for h264 acc inside the fglrx package,but no header files at all
redeeman: it's probably horribly broken
redeeman: so broken that they don't even bother letting people try it
Kano: they hide the headers for use ;)
redeeman: though that still doesn't explain why they ship it
redeeman: amd is impossible to deal with
Kano: the dont need to ship the binary when the dont want to use it...
redeeman: i told them like... almost a year ago, to remove the text saying that the 64bit drivers requires 32bit emulation to install and/or work
redeeman: nothing has happened
Kano: i have got nothing about 32 bit libs, i install em anyways in a 64 bit install to let some games which are binary only work
redeeman: i have a chroot for 32bit stuff
redeeman: i don't want my 64bit environment polluted
redeeman: besides, it's NOT required
redeeman: they should not write that it is
Kano: but for games you need the 32 bit mesa lib
redeeman: .... to be in the chroot
Kano: well that lib needs to be replaced anyway
redeeman: yes, and that's perfectly fine
redeeman: but the 64bit driver does NOT need the 32bit driver
Kano: i guess that was a linking failure
redeeman: no
redeeman: imagine this:
redeeman: you have a 64bit no-multilib install on 1 partition
redeeman: a 32bit on another
redeeman: what I want, is to be able to install ONLY 64bit stuff on my 64bit install
redeeman: and then install the 32bit driver on the 32bit install
Kano: i guess they fixed this issue
redeeman: the issue is ONLY in the documentation
redeeman: which SAYS 64bit driver must have 32bit emul packages
Kano: maybe ccc is 32 bit only ,dont know
redeeman: which it does not require
redeeman: this causes certain distribution maintainers to make the packages depend on 32bit emul stuff
redeeman: making it block on 64bit only profile
redeeman: because "upstream says so"
redeeman: so i request AMD stop being morons and write proper dependency list
redeeman: but they refuse
Kano: well a standard user wants that 32 bit apps work with this 64 bit os
redeeman: yes yes, and standard users won't be affected at all
Kano: therefore suse started with extremely doubled libs
Kano: they had everything twice basically...
redeeman: but i am not a standard user, i want this nonstandard config, and i cant easily because amd writes it shouldn't be done
redeeman: it's bascially the reason i didn't buy an AMD card :P
Kano: well the problem are not the amd cards
Kano: you can put em into the dustbin if you dont like em
redeeman: if their support chain cant even change a simple text, i don't even want to think about other things
Kano: but the problem are the laptops
Kano: you can not replace the card only the full system
redeeman: morale to the story: avoid AMD like the plague
Kano: i can not avoid it
Kano: my pci-e cards died from ati (only x700 cards, no real loss anyway)
Kano: i have to provide support for em
redeeman: i weap for you
Kano: maybe i build a agp system again to use my last 9800 pro card with it..
Kano: did not get a pci-e ati card yet
redeeman: my laptop has 9700 pro
Kano: and of course i will not pay for it
Kano: for basic test i find users with ssh login for me ;)
Kano: then i do not need to worry about exchanging cards, works until major faults are in the driver
redeeman: we can only hope intel comes around with larrabee and hurts amd/nvidia badly
redeeman: maybe then they will care
Kano: well intel gma 500 sucks badly
redeeman: yes
redeeman: but that's not an intel created thing either
redeeman: amd still has a chance though
Kano: they should not licence that crap...
redeeman: if they manage to make the R700 stuff work soon
redeeman: Kano: agreed, but as i hear, it was a mistake
redeeman: done by management without talking to developers
RobbieAB: AMD are doomed, the voices on the net say so...
redeeman: imagination technologies are really the worst bunch of morons ever to be on this earth
mo0n_sniper: ok I'm off, michaellarabel maybe you could see if there is any interes in a windows port of pts
Kano: RobbieAB: maybe ati oss is the last change for users before ati dies ;)
Kano: chance
redeeman: amd does seem to be a bunch of wusses
RobbieAB: Kano: Did I forget to add the sarcasm tags? ;)
RobbieAB: nVidia will always have a competitor, Intel will always have a competitor...
redeeman: i believe AMD could have advanced the open drivers much faster, much cheaper
Kano: well without oss drivers there would be no drivers for em sooner or later
RobbieAB: It's the nature of the game, the monopoly stagnates without competition until competition returns.
Kano: amd wants to sell the factories already, because they really need money
Kano: next stell i to sell amd to nvidia as they want to produce x86 cpus
RobbieAB: So? Who said AMD would be the competitor to either company?
Kano: but they dont need ati gpus
Kano: nvidia bought some patents from transmeta already
redeeman: mismanagement really kills otherwise healthy companies
Kano: i guess they want to produce something for the increasing netbook market
Kano: because intel is no good player ;) next netbook gpu will be integrated into the cpu
Kano: and that means the 9400m would be useless
RobbieAB: notes which company is further along with the merging CPU and GPU
redeeman: Kano: i hear intel is shrinking gma 950 and integrating with atom
Kano: yes, that means the external nvidia design is not optimal...
RobbieAB: Why do you think AMD acquired ATI?
redeeman: so they are really doing it? it wasnt just rumors?
Kano: well if i would be nvidia i would provide arm gpu+nvidia gpu on one chip as first step and then try to get a x86 licence
Kano: their top chips are already much more integrated than intel i7,so that should be no big deal
RobbieAB: Kano: not worth it, ARM+GPU can't compete in the netbook market easily, due to the inability to run winXP
redeeman: fuck x86
redeeman: m$ can just fuck themselves and provide an OS for ARM
RobbieAB: Not going to happen.
Kano: RobbieAB: use it as smartphone then
redeeman: no netbook manufacturer has the guys
Kano: a smartphone that can run little 3d games
redeeman: guts*
RobbieAB: Kano: fine, which immediately cuts you of from the critical market.
redeeman: but if they did, they would win massively
redeeman: it could have significantly better battery time
RobbieAB: The key here is legacy software, x86 legacy runs happily enough on any current netbook.
Kano: RobbieAB: you know that iphone is using arm core?
redeeman: lol, nobody cares about legacy software on netbooks
Kano: think of iphone 3d
redeeman: they do have the power to severely hurt m$ with it
RobbieAB: Kano: I do, and I know the iPhone is not playing in the netbook market.
Kano: RobbieAB: not yet
RobbieAB: redeeman: wrong, I know a LOT of people who care about the "legacy" software.
redeeman: not on netbooks
Kano: the chips will be really similar soon
RobbieAB: redeeman: especially on the netbooks.
redeeman: Kano: a new arm cortex 8/9 destroys the iphones arm
RobbieAB: netbooks are cheap and portable, if they can run MS Office, they are good.
redeeman: lol they don't nee m$ office
redeeman: they can use openoffice all fine
RobbieAB: redeeman: Problem here is too many changes at once
redeeman: not really
RobbieAB: Yes really.
redeeman: first generation netbook has went all fine with linux
redeeman: if they suddenly had 2-3 times the battery life
redeeman: with better fitted applications
redeeman: it would be much better for 99% of the users
RobbieAB: Yes, first gen had Linux, but targetted the consumer market.
RobbieAB: The big netbook prize is the business market, which is a lot harder to steal.
RobbieAB: In work, I see the following apps as being the key: MS Office, Adobe Creative Suite, ...
redeeman: lol that's crap
redeeman: nobody can do adobe crapwork on a netbook
redeeman: and even if they could
RobbieAB: Get them on Linux and ARM, and I can sell 200 netbooks in a week.
redeeman: they shouldn't
RobbieAB: Why not?
redeeman: lol 200 is nothing
redeeman: because the netbook is too small to get productive
RobbieAB: That's the entire College ;)
Kano: well ubuntu 9.04 will support arm netbooks
redeeman: the netbook is there to CONSUME stuff
redeeman: not create it
RobbieAB: redeeman: so? Docking station set-up?
RobbieAB: Problem solved.
redeeman: dockingstation is SO 1990
Kano: dont know where to download the needed flashplayer however,but as the iphone has one... there must be a player somewhere ;)
RobbieAB: It's still a major part of the office environment.
RobbieAB: Small laptop, big screen on desk.
redeeman: lol dockingstations are out
redeeman: im a consultant, i regularly go onsite
redeeman: and people are throwing docking stations out
redeeman: it's an extremely rare event seeing one
RobbieAB: Well, I see people using them with smaller laptops.
Kano: netbooks are mainly for surfing the web, watching videos on youtube has to work, mail and maybe change a document with openoffice. would be nice if some games would work however...
RobbieAB: Kano: that is the consumer (domestic) netbook.
redeeman: lol screw youtube
RobbieAB: The business one is a VERY different beast.
Kano: redeeman: when you can nto watch it you can not sell any netbook ;)
RobbieAB: Business netbook: A SMALL laptop.
redeeman: Kano: i already have
Kano: a netbook?
RobbieAB: With a modern CPU it can run all the apps it needs to, drive a projector, and slip into the hanbag
redeeman: i've resold some eee's
Kano: but youcan watch youtube
RobbieAB: handbag*
redeeman: Kano: not the way I configured them
Kano: bad boy ;)
redeeman: it's called good customer service
Kano: well firefox find the plugin itself usually
redeeman: it fails to install
redeeman: i made sure
Kano: really bad boy ;)
RobbieAB: Anyway, it's way past my bedtime, so I'm off...
Kano: do you know that debians gnome meta package installs an opensource swf plugin?
redeeman: no
Kano: as real dependency, not even a suggest or recommend
redeeman: abominable behavior
Kano: really stupid, as you have to disable it in iceweasel then
redeeman: i don't install gnome
Kano: swfdec-mozilla is a dependency
Kano: i dont like that, you have to kick on every flash to run it
Kano: and it is not fully compatible
avazhang: hi all, can somebody here tell me how to merge the results in different machines into one picture?
avazhang: Something like the picture on this webpage http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd_shanghai_opensolaris&num=2
DaSkreech: hi guys
DaSkreech: Can someone tell me what AMD Dragon is?

< Phoronix IRC Home

Latest Hardware Reviews
  1. Sumo Lounge Emperor
  2. Gallium3D Continues Improving OpenGL For Older Radeon GPUs
  3. 15-Way Open vs. Closed Source NVIDIA/AMD Linux GPU Comparison
  4. Nouveau vs. NVIDIA Linux Comparison Shows Shortcomings
Latest Software Articles
  1. The Cost Of Ubuntu Disk Encryption
  2. Btrfs vs. EXT4 vs. XFS vs. F2FS On Linux 3.10
  3. AMD Radeon R600 GPU LLVM 3.3 Back-End Testing
  4. F2FS File-System Shows Regressions On Linux 3.10
Latest Linux News
  1. QEMU 1.5 Supports VGA Passthrough, Better USB 3.0
  2. Handbrake 0.9.9 Supports OpenCL Offloading
  3. Freedreno Gallium3D Now Banging The Adreno A3XX
  4. Jolla Announces Their First Phone
  5. Mageia 3 Released, Still Using Legacy GRUB
  6. NetBSD 6.1 Brings In More Features
  7. Using Six Monitors With AMD's Open-Source Linux Driver
  8. Benchmarking The Intel P-State, CPUfreq Changes
  9. FreeBSD Still Working On Next-Gen Package Manager
  10. DNF Still Advancing As Experimental Yum For Fedora
  11. Logitech Begins Supporting Linux Users
Latest Forum Talk
  1. Mageia 3 Released, Still Using Legacy GRUB
  2. Jolla Announces Their First Phone
  3. Ubuntu To Look At Replacing Firefox With Chromium
  4. What Would You Like To See Next?
  5. QEMU 1.5 Supports VGA Passthrough, Better USB 3.0
  6. FreeBSD Still Working On Next-Gen Package Manager
  1. Computers
  2. Display Drivers
  3. Graphics Cards
  4. Motherboards
  5. Peripherals
  6. Processors
  7. Software
  8. Operating Systems
  9. All Articles
  1. Linux Benchmarking
  2. OpenBenchmarking.org
  3. Phoronix Test Suite