Intel AES-NI For Ubuntu Home Encryption
Supported by modern Intel processors is the AES instruction set, which is designed to improve the speed of encryption and decryption on the CPU for AES, the Advanced Encryption Standard. Under Ubuntu Linux, even for supported hardware, the Intel AES-NI capability is not taken advantage of when enabling its data encryption feature. The Intel AES-NI support can be easily enabled, but what is the impact on performance? Here are some benchmarks.
Last month was an article entitled Ubuntu 11.10 Home Encryption Performance, which looked at the performance impact of using the home folder data encryption feature on the soon-to-be-released Ubuntu 11.10. For older hardware (Core 2 Duo with a mobile HDD) the impact of encrypting the user's home directory varied from 10~20% with heavy disk workloads. Using an Intel Sandy Bridge (Core i5) notebook with an Intel SSD caused less of an impact compared to no encryption at all. One of the emails that came in following last month's article was from Canonical's Dustin Kirkland.
Ask for interesting tests, and you shall receive. This article is looking at that the Intel AES-NI acceleration with Ubuntu eCryptfs home encryption. Testing was done with an Ubuntu 11.10 daily snapshot from 5 October 2011. For simplicity (and since the notebook was conveniently ready when arriving back from Oktoberfest), the same HP EliteBook with an Intel Core i5 2520M (Sandy Bridge) with Intel 160GB X-25 SSD was used for this AES-NI comparison.
The AES-NI instruction set has been supported by Intel CPUs going back to the Clarkdale/Arrandale family, but there are some exceptions in the models that support this new acceleration instruction set. The AES-NI support continues with Sandy Bridge (there are some unsupported models here too) and should be fully supported across all Ivy Bridge CPUs. The Core i5 2520M supports the AES New Instructions. The AES support can also be checked via the flags from /proc/cpuinfo under Linux. The Linux cryptography support can also be checked from /proc/crypto to ensure aesni-intel is loaded. With the default Phoronix Test Suite test location being within ~/.phoronix-test-suite/, all tests are being executed from within the encrypted home area.
The clean Ubuntu 11.10 snapshot was tested in its default configuration with home encryption enabled and then after loading the "aesni-intel" kernel module before logging into the encrypted user account. The Intel AES-NI instructions have been supported under Linux going back to early 2009.
As far as the slated improvements for AES-NI, Intel documentation provides the following:
The performance improvement expected with the use of AES-NI would depend on the applications and how much of the application time is spent in encryption and decryption. At the algorithm level, using AES-NI can provide significant speedup of AES. For non-parallel modes of AES operation such as CBC-encrypt AES-NI can provide a 2-3 fold gain in performance over a completely software approach. For parallelizable modes such as CBC-decrypt and CTR, AES-NI can provide a 10x improvement over software solutions.
Since the Sandy Bridge processor is already quite fast, this encryption comparison was done with all four threads enabled (two cores + Hyper Threading) and then when disabling the Hyper Threading and multi CPU support from the BIOS, so that only a single processing thread was available. The first of these results are with the stock settings (all four threads available). During the testing process, the Phoronix Test Suite also monitored the CPU usage automatically (by setting the MONITOR=cpu.usage environmental variable prior to starting the phoronix-test-suite client).
Latest Articles & Reviews
Latest Linux News
Most Viewed News This Week