also you could test out your favourite apps behavior in the different overlays and decide based on their functioning. this is the best test in my opinion.
For an X800 and any GPU before 690 or HD1xxx I would go with :
- Textured video off (Textured Video is primarily for GPUs with the AVIVO display controller, which don't have the older overlay)
- OpenGL overlay off (OpenGL overlay is for workstation apps only, and I believe it's ignored when Video overlay is enabled)
- Video overlay on (the pre-5xx overlay included a lot of video processing HW -- on the later chips we used the silicon for a more flexible display controller and shaders instead)
... and go with Xv.
Here's my xorg.conf's device section
Should I comment TexturedXrender?Code:Section "Device" Identifier "aticonfig-Device" Driver "fglrx" Option "VideoOverlay" "on" Option "OpenGLOverlay" "off" Option "FSAAEnable" "on" Option "FSAAScale" "4" # Option "Textured2D" "true" Option "TexturedXrender" "true" EndSection
You might want to turn it off while you're experimenting with video settings but I believe TexturedXRender is independent of TexturedVideo.
I believe you just need something like Option "TexturedVideo" "off" to make sure it is disabled. Of course it may be disabled by default on your card in which case you wouldn't see any difference. I'm not sure what the results are if you have both TexturedVideo and VideoOverlay enabled.
Remember that there are two ways of setting options in fglrx -- the conf file and the amdpcsdb file. I'm fairly sure (but not 100% sure) that amdpcsdb "wins" in the event of a conflict between the two files. My understanding is that the aticonfig utility will set both files but I haven't played with it myself yet.
Last edited by bridgman; 02-09-2008 at 05:46 PM.
Here's a question, should I just leave those options out of xorg.conf, remove /etc/ati/* and reinstall the driver? Will this let the driver choose the best option?
I'm guessing since you have two different technologies, it has to choose one automatically since someone is bound to screw up.
My guess is that running aticonfig with the right options would do the job as well. I don't have the options in front of me but I think there's an aticonfig command line option that dumps 'em out. Matthew showed me a few weeks ago but I'm not remembering...
xv is the one to choose if it works. For me, xv is pretty much broken with the latest driver, though, so I'm using the opengl overlay, which kinda sucks. Lots of video tearing, and in general just annoying.
OpenGLOverlay is for specific workstation apps which "float" a second layer of display information over the work area. It should be turned off on consumer cards.
You don't need OpenGLOverlay to play video through OpenGL, btw.
VideoOverlay is for pre-5xx cards which had video acceleration hardware built into the overlay block. For more recent cards (5xx and higher GPUs), or when you are running Compiz, you need to use TexturedVideo.
There is an aticonfig option which dumps out the commands, probably --help, but I don't think it goes into detail about when/how/why you would use each option.