Interesting to see the ODROID-X running as well as it did. The question I have though is it because of the kernel, compiler and file system that is slowing the Tegra 3 down?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Quad-Core ODROID-X Battles NVIDIA Tegra 3
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by ldesnogu View PostIf you want to push power consumption make sure NEON is being used on the 4 cores. Video encoding/decoding with FFmpeg and 4 threads should do it
Comment
-
Originally posted by Darkseider View PostInteresting to see the ODROID-X running as well as it did. The question I have though is it because of the kernel, compiler and file system that is slowing the Tegra 3 down?
Comment
-
Originally posted by ssvb View PostFor the start, Tegra 3 obviously was not running at 1.4GHz clock frequency even for single-threaded workloads (contrary to what is said in the article). I have a dejavu feeling
Comment
-
Originally posted by Rallos Zek View PostYou talking Nvidia here, the reason Linus said fuck you to them is cause they do not want their hardware to work well with the Linux OSS stack, of course its gonna get trashed in the bentmarks. Nvidia is a hardware non grata if you use and love Linux!
Comment
-
Originally posted by ssvb View PostIf you want to maximize the power consumption for testing purposes, synthetic cpuburn test programs seem to be a lot more effective than any real workload. Here was my attempt: https://github.com/ssvb/ssvb.github....b-cpuburn-a9.S. Maybe somebody else could do even better.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ldesnogu View PostYour program doesn't use NEON datapath, did you try it?
edit: Or do you mean NEON arithmetic instructions? Experiments with an ammeter show that load/store instructions are by far consuming more power, so it's a waste executing anything other than VLD in the NEON unit. Cortex-A8 is a bit different, because it supports dual-issue.Last edited by ssvb; 22 August 2012, 02:14 PM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ssvb View Postedit: Or do you mean NEON arithmetic instructions? Experiments with an ammeter show that load/store instructions are by far consuming more power, so it's a waste executing anything other than VLD in the NEON unit. Cortex-A8 is a bit different, because it supports dual-issue.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ldesnogu View PostYes that's what I meant. I'm surprised by your result given the way VLD and VST work on C-A9.
As for ODROID-X, it's good that they have spotted the power consumption issue in time and added a passive heatsink. Though their claim that software video decoding "is not the normal use environment" sounds like a really poor excuse. A dedicated cpuburn program can heat the CPU a lot more than software video decoding, additionally loading GPU with some heavy shaders and making use of various hardware decoders at the same time could probably cause some really bad problems without proper cooling. But I guess, having the theoretical peak power consumption significantly exceeding the typical power consumption for normal workload is to be expected. The SoC just needs to be safely throttled when it is put into extreme conditions. As I can see, there is some work ongoing on the thermal framework in the arm linux kernel mailing list. Having a passive heatsink probably ensures better chances for the thermal framework to kick in before it is too late
BTW, the inconsistent Tegra3 performance can be also probably explained by a weird behavior of the frequency scaling governer. Whether the CPU really needs to be throttled or the governor is just misconfigured out of blue, or something else is wrong still needs to be figured out.
Perhaps dual issuing integer ld/st with NEON DP might require more power?Last edited by ssvb; 22 August 2012, 03:45 PM.
Comment
Comment