You could keep for yourself such bull. Kubuntu was Ubuntu killer, so they had to drop it. If Kubuntu was obsolete then everything was.
Originally Posted by funkSTAR
You need to test this with a more modern game... maybe Oilrush or Xonotic would be an option? As it is these benchmarks hardly reflect real life gaming performance unless you play these games with old tech.
Yea, KWin doesn't unredirect fullscreen windows at all by default, because it causes annoying screen corruption when combined with overlay windows (like the Amarok OSD). So while it should be considered a bug, it still explains the poor performance. To be fair, all tested games should have been run in windowed mode, in order to truly compare the compositing performance, and not the unredirection performance.
Though at least for me, using latest Catalyst drivers with KWin causes screen blackening, so I have to keep it off regardless...
you forgot the MATE desktop.
but other than that quite expected results
Thanks, that was a very interesting read!
Originally Posted by drago01
in a perfect world the window manager should have ZERO impact on gaming performance with a fullscreen 3d game.
Which makes all results with the nvidia driver look VERY fishy. Something is not done right there.
I don't know what distro you use or how you obtained your Xfce setup, but Xfce's performance is regularly ruined by changes/additions made by distributions (like the mountain of sluggish fail that is Xubuntu).
Originally Posted by schmidtbag
I ran openbox for years, then i ran fluxbox for years. I'm extremely minimalist and greatly value responsiveness from my desktop.
These days I run Xfce, session managed and all, on ArchLinux and am happy with how it performs.
How you can be a fan and user of LXDE but say something like "i'd rather use unity [than Xfce]" boggles my mind. But each to their own.
<insert fanboyism here over Xfce trumping the competition in the benchmark results>
Oil Rush performance
I've tested performance of Oil Rush on my PC running Ubuntu 11.10 with different shells:
AMD Athlon(tm) 64 X2 Dual Core Processor 4400+
nVidia 9600 GT NVIDIA Driver Version:280.13
2 GB RAM
fulscreen 1920x1080, anti-aliasing off, graphics medium, textures high
Enlightment E17 (with ecomporh enabled) from 39 to 60 fps (mostly 46-50 fps)
Razor-qt from 37 to 60 fps (mostly 41-50 fps)
Unity (using Daniel van Vugt PPA's for Compiz and Unity)
Gnome Classic (no effects)
all four of them are locked at 30 fps (sometimes going to 28 fps)
I've used built-in fps counter of the game and played on the same map always loading the same save.